Fish Tale Grill Dinner Menu

Explore the many options offered on our dinner menu at our sit down restaurant in Cape Coral. Our culinary team has created a marvel for all five senses, from creative appetizers that include our signature tower platter to salads, pasta, seafood baskets, and even options for land lovers. So we invite you to visit our sit down restaurant in Cape Coral, settle in, and experience the freshest seafood in Southwest Florida.

View Our Dinner Menu

Check Out Our Other Menus

The Perfect Way to Start the Day

Brunch Menu

View
Dilectable Mid-Day Meals

Lunch Menu

View
Inspired Cocktails

Drink Menu

View

See What Others Have to Say

Mikaela W.

Fishtale Grill never disappoints! My favorite thing on the menu is the Lobster BLT Melt. It is SO good! Their outdoor seating space is wonderful as well! I highly recommend!

Margaret H.

It is only seldom that I am compelled to add a review. Everything was so good I was about moved to tears.  Oysters were amazing. Lobster sublime. Service by David was considerate, fast and gracious.  Will definitely recommend it to everyone that has a chance to be in the area.

Alex H.

Every time we come here the food and service is beyond amazing! The best seafood in the area and the outdoor seating is perfect!

Rene K.

This was the first time we came out to the Cape for dinner at the Fishtale Grill, but it certainly won’t be the last!  Hayley provided ah-mazing service, and the food was divine!  My honey had the Seafood Paella, and I devoured the Lobster and Crab Stuffed Shrimp.  Of course, we had salty Blue Point Oysters to start.  This was a meal worthy of 10 stars!  Hayley also told us about the oyster specials available on Saturdays and Sundays for brunch (Gulf oysters are $1.00 each).  We will be back again soon!

Kimberly M.

Our server was amazing!! She treated us like she had known us for yrs! We had the best time here and the food was top notch!! Definitely recommend!!!

Ask About Our Giftcards

Purchase A Gift Card